President Donald Trumps first prime-time address from the Oval Office was his opportunity to make a case for his border security plan. Instead, it highlighted just how little Trump understood the problems he hoped a border wall would fix economic costs, crime and drug trafficking and how desperate he is to blame Democrats for the government shutdown.
The federal government remains shut down for one reason and one reason only, he said. Because Democrats will not fund border security.
But this is far from an accurate assessment of the shutdown. During negotiations aimed at avoiding a shutdown, Democrats offered to approve $1.3 billion to fund surveillance measures and fortified fencing directed at border security. Approval for funding was withheld for Trumps border wall.
The one who has welcomed responsibility for sparking shutdown was Trump himself when he met with Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer in December.
I will take the mantle. I will be the one to shut it down, Trump said.
Trump then moved to misrepresent the effects illegal immigration has on employment, claiming it drives down jobs and wages. But employers frequently point to a shortage of immigrant labor as responsible for driving up costs a tight labor market has made it difficult for industries to employ low-skilled immigrant labor to keep down costs. Studies have also concluded that whatever strain illegal immigration puts on public services is readily made up for by taxes paid by immigrants. Undocumented immigrants filed nearly 4.4 million income tax returns in 2015, paying up to $23.6 billion in income taxes.
Trump also said his wall would help address drug trafficking and the opioid crisis. Not only does he misunderstand these problems, his prescription wouldnt help either.
Illegal drugs that make their way into the United States from Mexico typically enter through legal ports of entry like airports and rail stations. Likewise, the fentanyl fueling Americas opioid crisis doesnt usually go through unsecured portions of our southern border.
Instead, it enters through packages mailed from China or by smugglers driving through border checkpoints. A border wall that secures vast stretches of desert addresses none of these narcotics trafficking techniques.
Trump frequently exaggerates and misrepresents, and he was no different during his prime-time address. He pointed to the number of immigrants with criminal records arrested by ICE, but he neglected to mention that many were guilty of immigration-related offenses rather than violent crimes.
This continues Trumps habit of exaggerating the threat posed by immigrants who statistically commit crime at lower rates than those born in America.
Trumps willingness to place livelihoods, solutions and truth on the line for a game of chicken is dangerous to the safety of immigrants and Americans alike. Trump used last nights prime-time address to merely double down on the collision course.
